Friday, February 8, 2008

It's something every denizen of the Maharashtra state must know and follow in her heart. You cannot voice your opinion about the Shiv Sainiks in public. Be it reporters from esteemable dailies or naive apolitical girls in their early twenties. The papers report facts, not their analysis.I remember once tugging at my dad's sleeve while in a local train, and asking him if the sainiks were gangsters. (That's probably what any kid would assume at seeing the clippings of the rampant violence set off by a couple in love, by...well... holding hands.) It didn't take my mother even a split second to turn to me with eyes made the size of saucers and place a viciously shaking finger over my lips. The co-passengers instinctively looked radially outward from the spot at which we were standing. (Ah! what a perfect helicopter view that must have made!) Welcome to Aamchi Mumbai!

And now, here we have our man spitting venom at an actor, who merely decided to give something back (in his capacity) to the society. What is our man's point? We'll, if its Bombay that has given Mr. Bachchan the fame and money, why are the girls from Lucknow his beneficiaries? I will not discuss here if he does have a point in this or not, conditioned as i am since childhood to stay mum about the brand 'Thackeray', i join the despicable band of the puppet reporters and dailies i just denounced.

But there is something else that is bothering me. We have decided to blindly drop the reigns of our mind and let it run just about anywhere,like a horse without blinkers.I say 'we', because on an average, every Maharashtrian household harbours a sainik.What has led to this situation? The man whose name was hailed till yesterday, whose movies like Deewar and Sholay we watched just last night, whose name we swear by, had his home stoned today,by us. What is it that holds the key to the public mind that is capable of bringing about just a drastic change in the public mood overnight? It was not that we didn't know about the school before. The process of planning and acquisition has been on since months. It's only when our man spelt it out that we decided to express our rage. And who were the perpetrators and the victims? Aamchi maanus of course.(it included a few odd bhel puri waalas who were unfortunate enough to be at the scene, and who of course did not have any political affiliations).All for what? A girls' school.

I refuse to attribute this to one man's charisma.In my opinion, there's a lot more to the story. The unemployment, the frustration or rather sheer boredom. The bored mass needs entertainment, it needs a means to vent out its passion. So it needs an excuse, that our man provides. I wouldn't say it was misplaced faith in his followers, I'm sure our man fully realised the impact of his words.(It comes from years of practice and experience after all)
Yet, the party needs to keep up its followers' spirits. It's like throwing a ball for your pet dog to go and fetch it back, to keep him in good health, you know.We'll now his ball is back, and so is the media. Is this desirable for our man? Mmm, maybe. Was it desirable for the state? I don't think so. So isn't our man talking about the betterment of that very state? Very much so.

What we need is education. Not in the sense of being able to sign our names and do rudimentary calculations.But in the sense of acquiring the capability of reception without reaction. At this point i fantasise, how would things be if we could all really smirk at our man and say "nice try man, better luck next time. Next issue please...".We are living through a crisis. At this moment, we need not look to Western learning to come to our aid, even the Indian school of thought can do the job. So arise and awake O Mighty Saffron men! Use Hindutva as your bastion and Maharashtra's culture as your cushion, but at least try to have good intentions. This is definitely not the culture one wishes to 'protect'.

4 comments:

Deepu said...

Consider this situation..

suppose i am big big big fan of iron maiden. one day in college prof announced that the next day's lesson is very very crucial and demanded everyone to attend. unfortunately iron maiden's rock show is also on the same day. i, being a big fan of iron maiden chooses to bunk that very very very imp lecture and attend the concert. From my perspective it is nothing wrong. from the prof's perspective i am an irresponsible spoiled kid.


similarly for you who don't idolize raj thackrey, may be those followers seem like uneducated fools. But for them what they are doing is right. First raj became an idol for so many people. How ? It definitely isn't an easy task. may be there is some truth that you and me who are not his followers are missing, just like the prof missing the msg of iron maiden's rock. we simply didn't face the situations that daily labourers and people living in slums face. so we don't know why they follow him. hence we just can't attribute to simple uneducation. case in point - most of the communists are well educated. still their theories are soooooo unacceptable....


BTW i ain't a sainik. i don't know anything about it.

Disha said...

sandeep....sigh!things like these don't make for a good 'discussion' topic. i have learnt my lesson on several occassions. but i do get your point. if i agree wid it or not is another issue all together :)

i'm glad u visited.

Disha said...

@the fingers on the keyboard

weired name to pick....tho interesting overall ;)

thankyou for rephrasing (tho in a much better way, pat pat)exactly what i wanted to convey but didn't manage to apparently.

Disha said...

@the fingers on the keyboard

read Night by Ellie Wiesel if u haven awready.